Update: The Radion has been updated to a generation 2 model and a Pro model. Here’s my review of both of the new lights.

After much researching and deliberating, I’m testing out the EcoTech Marine Radion LED fixture as a possible LED setup for my SPS-heavy 90g tank.

This page will serve as a homepage for the Radion LED experiment and any updates about it will be posted here.

First up, my review of the Radion:

Note: There is an error in the show. The royal blue LEDs are 460 nm in wavelength and the blues are 475 nm. YouTube doesn’t allow me to upload a new version of the show on the same link so I’m leaving the show as is with the above note.

 

Second, here is EcoTech’s product page on the Radion, complete with pictures, graphs, etc: Link to the Radion

Third, I am a dealer for EcoTech Marine (even for you Canadians out there) so if you are interested in pre-ordering a Radion (they’ll ship about Sept 30th), please let me know.

———————————————-

People have been asking me to post a picture of my tank lit up with both the 250W Halide and the Radion. Below is that picture. Halide is on the left of the photo, Radion on the right.

Something that I’ve always found interesting is how white my 20K reefluxes look. To me, they look more 14K than the traditional 20K which is known for being heavily blue. Certainly when I have the Radion on a 20K spectrum, the Radion’s 20K light is far bluer than the Reeflux 20K.

FYI, the halide bulb is 2 months old as of 9.13.2011

Halide on the left, Radion on the right

————————————————————–

After 2 weeks with the Radion, I have seen no bleaching whatsoever with the corals underneath it, so I’ve upped the hours it runs per day from 4 to 5.

I’m also running the fixture @ 100% on all LEDs. I’ll admit it would probably have been safer to ramp up the power of the Radion, but since the Radion is a 250W metal halide replacement, and my corals were used to a 250@ halide, I felt safe running the Radion @ 100% and simply increasing the time it was on. Plus I’m impatient. So far, so good.

————————————————————-
I mentioned the Radion in this show so I’m putting here:

————————————————————-

My corals continue to look great so I’ve increased the time the Radion is on to 6 full hours.

There is lots of chatter about red LEDs growing algae and I’ve seen no algae growth under the Radion.

————————————————————

Just about 1 month into the experiment, all my corals look great and I’ve increased the time the Radion is on to 7 hours. My full photo period will be 7.5 hrs.

At this point, I’m very tempted to get rid of the halide on the other side of my tank and replace it with a Radion. However, patient is a virtue so I’m holding off…for now. I also want to make sure this experiment gets ample time to run before I make a final decision.

———————————————————–

I’m close to 2 months into the Radion experiment and things are going very smoothly. The Radion has been running at full strength (100% on all channels, 100% intensity) for just about a month and my corals look great – no bleaching, no noticeable slowing in growth. Growth patterns remain the same as under halides as well.

Good news all the way around and it makes me eager to make my tank 100% Radion LEDs.

There have been some questions below so I’ll answer the common ones:

- How does the shimmer compare to your metal halide lamps?

It looks the same to me. Perhaps a little more subdued, but not noticeable. I still get plenty of shimmer with the Radion

How far off the water do you have the Radion?

About 10″.

How is the spread?

Excellent. I think 1 Radion per 2′x2′ area is fine. If you want crazy PAR readings like a 400W Halide, use 2 per 2′x’2 area.

I also like how the Radion has very minimal spot lighting effect which means my tank doesn’t look like an interrogation room.

- How are you acclimating your corals?

Since the Radion has about 10% better PAR numbers than my 250W halide lamp, I’m ran the Radion @ 100% for 4 hrs, then added an hour per week until I reach my full photoperiod of 7.5 hrs.

NOTE: If you are switching from lower intensity lighting like power compacts or low wattage T5′s or Metal Halides, it won’t hurt to run the Radion at a 50% intensity setting for a short time, then work your way up t0 100% on the short time setting. Once your corals are ok with the new intense light, increase the time the Radion in on. Remember, slow is better.

How much do the Radions cost?

EcoTech Marine has a minimum advertised price (MAP) policy which stipulates the price for the Radion cannot be below $749. In keeping with EcoTech’s policy, I’m selling the Radions for $749 shipped to the continental USA.

————————————————————-

12.8.2011 Mr. Saltwater Tank’s Radion Experiment Update

After 4 months of testing the Radion out, it is time for a full update.

(and don’t forget the bonus video below showing my Radion program)

Bonus Video Showing My Radion Program (link opens in a new window)

————————————————————-

Since people are asking, here’s a video of the shimmer produced in my tank  by the Radion (link opens in a new window)

{ 123 comments… read them below or add one }

Sal July 17, 2012 at 12:08 pm

Gotcha ok I asked about them back in feb and didnt get a response that’s the only reason I posted that

Mark Callahan July 17, 2012 at 1:55 pm

Check your email Ed!

Mike July 22, 2012 at 8:13 pm

Mark,
Just wondering if you are now using natural mode on your radions? If so, have you altered the time/intensity? If not, did you make up your own program and care to share? Thanks

Mark Callahan July 22, 2012 at 8:30 pm

Mike…I’ve only used artificial mode. I’m still tweaking my program and I’ll share it once I’m done.

Mike July 22, 2012 at 8:37 pm

Great, looking forward to seeing it.

tuyen August 10, 2012 at 2:21 pm

great info on the radion and i love your tank.

Mark Callahan August 10, 2012 at 2:24 pm

Thanks tuyen!

Travis August 25, 2012 at 8:27 am

I’m very curious to know what supplemental lighting you are running. When you are making the switch on your lights you still have a pretty well lite tank. What else are you running in conjunction with the Radions?

Have you grabbed any par values without the additional supplemental lights on?

Mark Callahan August 25, 2012 at 10:49 pm

Travis…the supplement light was a 36″ reef brite LED bar I had laying around. This tank was 100% Radion for 4 months before I sold it before I moved. All PAR values shows are with no supplemental lights on.

Travis August 26, 2012 at 11:59 am

Awesome thanks for the info.

Jameson August 30, 2012 at 10:28 am

HI Mark. One question, i also have a mac. How did you run the radion software on your mac?

Jeff September 20, 2012 at 6:11 am

Hi Mark,

so im thinking of making the (costly) step towards radions as well, unlike you however im currently using two 2 bulb t5 rails (4t5s in total) and was wondering if you could give me a tip on how to gradually make the transition.

tank specs:

450 l (about 118g)
150 cm long (59″)
60 cm deep (24″)

also im currently trying to come up with a brace to keep the radions over the tank and the simplest manner will place them just over 10cm above the water surface, too close?

Thank you in advance for your tips and awesome regards from Switzerland.
-jeff-

Roger October 3, 2012 at 4:19 pm

Mark,

Very nice tank and I appreciate your comments on your website and in your videos. I’ve been looking at the Radion and the TMC LEDS. I have not been able to find any information from you regarding your experience with the TMC 1000 or 1500 LEDs. I would be interested in any thoughts that you have on the Radion compared to TMC.

Thanks,
Roger

Mark Callahan October 3, 2012 at 4:24 pm

Roger..the TMC is a completely different animal from the Radion. Comparing them would be like comparing apples to oranges.

Roger October 3, 2012 at 4:39 pm

Mark, not sure I follow. Maybe I should give you a bit more information on my tanks. First is a 72x30x24 (d) FWLR which will evolve into SPS & LPS reef. It currently has 3x400w 20k MH with bulbs that will soon need to be replaced. Second tank is 48x36x30 (d) reef currently with all SPS. It has 2x400w 20k MH. I am looking into the Radion and/or TMC 1000 or 1500′s. Any additional thoughts or comments would be appreciated.
Roger

Matt October 3, 2012 at 5:40 pm

Roger… The TMC units are not the same beast as the Radions … you really can’t compare them as they are at completely different levels of the led game…

If you want just simple leds that can be categorised as plain lights in a box then go for the TMC… If you have grand coral plans and need to know what your lights are doing and to expect good coral growth then go for the Radions…

Not saying either one is better than the other… But they both have their specific uses and strengths… The Radions have all the bases covered… The TMC’s can be utilised but it depends what you want from them… ;)

Jay H. October 29, 2012 at 12:05 am

Hey Mark, great site!! I have a 92 gallon corner reef tank and currently running a dimmable 120 watt led *bridgelux*. It is doing a good job covering majority of the tank considering i have no optics on it. I am strongly considering upgrading to a radion but was curious to know if 1 radion would be good or if I should do 2?? thanks Jay

Mark Callahan October 29, 2012 at 10:27 pm

Jay…1 Radion should get the job done considering you have a corner tank

Pete M October 30, 2012 at 12:07 pm

Mark, I have a 145g half round, just switched to 4 Kessil A150′s and like them, but looking for more light and effect. Was thinking of adding 1 Radion to the center for more light to start with some SPS, that would make the center of the tank much brighter while allowing some lower light areas on the sides? ALSO, could program moonlight for viewing later at night. Just curious about what you think with having a very bright center with the Radion.

John November 5, 2012 at 1:28 pm

Mark,
Great videos and info as always. I see that EcoTech is coming out with new Radion XR30 PRO and XR30 Generation 2. I’m setting up a 190gal 5′x27″x27″ tank and want to place three Radions over it. The XR30s have dropped by $150 and are more affordable. I’m being told that the new XR30s main difference will be color selection. The question is this, save some money and go with the older XR30 or wait for the new technology?
Thanks for the advice and keep up the great work!

Chris Beahm November 25, 2012 at 6:20 pm

Mark,

As John mentioned above me, I’m also curious as to your opinion on the 2nd generation versus the first. I would love to hear your thoughts. Great review, btw.

Lisa February 20, 2013 at 3:16 am

I had an LED fixture on my FW rank and hated the intensity of the shimmer. How does this compare to a fluorescent in that regard?

Luis April 4, 2013 at 11:23 am

Mark,
Of all the preset color spectrums (12k-20k) on my 1st gen Radion, which is best for coral growth/color?

im using one radion above my 60g 24x24x24 cube…wanting to do a mixed reef on it.
Thanks!

Leave a Comment

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.